Wikipedia

Parental rights movement

Not to be confused with Parents' rights movement.

The parental rights movement is a socially conservative political movement aimed at restricting schools' ability to teach or practice certain viewpoints on gender, sexuality and race without parental consent.[1][2][3]

One of the aims of the movement is to prevent schools from using the preferred pronouns or chosen names of transgender and non-binary youth without disclosing to, or gaining permission from parents.[4] More broadly, it aims to prevent the teaching of LGBT issues in public schools without parents' agreement.[2] Additionally, the parental rights movement has sought to increase parents' control over how children are taught about sexuality and race relations.[2]

The parental rights movement was brought to mainstream attention with the passage of the Parental Rights in Education Act in Florida, colloquially known as the Don't Say Gay law, by Governor Ron DeSantis. Since then, the movement has expanded across the US and Canada.[5][6] Proponents of the movement have claimed that they aim to prevent the indoctrination of children by LGBT activists,[4][7] while opponents of the movement argue that parental rights legislation endangers children by possibly outing them to unaccepting guardians.[8][9][10]

Definition

edit

Jen Gilbert, a professor at the University of Toronto's Ontario Institute for Studies in Education defined the movement as "a conservative movement to limit the influence of government in people's lives...more generally around the schooling, the parental rights movement has emerged as a movement to limit discussions of sexuality and gender in schools under the auspices of both protecting children and protecting parents' rights to raise children as they see fit".[3]

Media response

edit

The parental rights movement is viewed by some commentators as a form of pushback by conservatism against widespread acceptance of LGTBQ+ individuals and issues more broadly.[1][11] It has been described as a far-right movement by Dan Lett of the Winnipeg Free Press and by progressive-leaning outlets Salon.com and Michigan Advance.[12][13][14] The modern parental rights movement has been characterised by journalist Catherine Caruso as a resurgence of a similar movement in the 1990s.[15] Caruso likened the movement to the stigmatization of HIV during the AIDS epidemic. He identified similar themes with the 1994 bill Contract with America and the Contract with the American Family.

United States

edit
See also: 2020s anti-LGBT movement in the United States

Starting in 2020, parental rights activists in the United States have sought to regulate how race is taught in schools. Prompted by protests after the killings of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, schools increasingly added antiracist texts to their curricula and diversity, equity, and inclusion measures to their policies and practices. Advocacy from the parental rights movement led to a backlash against those trends, and a wave of laws and regulations—often codified as anti-critical race theory rules—were passed in 2021. Legal scholar LaToya Baldwin Clark connects the 2020s activism to historical backlash from White parents to "contestations over race" like desegregation.[16]

Groups have suggested that similar ideas by parental rights advocates, which have worked to restrict education on sex or sexuality, date back to the 1990s. According to research by the Public Religion Research Institute, the movement's failure to substantially shift norms in public education led many conservative Christian parents to withdraw their children from public schools and move to homeschooling or private schools.[17]

 
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis brought the parental rights movement to mainstream attention after he signed the Parental Rights in Education Act.

In 2022, the US state of Florida passed the Florida Parental Rights in Education Act, regulating all public schools in the state. The law prohibits public schools from having "classroom discussion" or giving "classroom instruction about sexual orientation or gender identity from kindergarten through third grade or in any manner deemed to be against state standards in all grades; prohibits public schools from adopting procedures or student support forms that maintain the confidentiality of a disclosure by a student, including of the gender identity or sexual orientation of a student, from parents; and requires public schools to bear all the costs of all lawsuits filed by aggrieved parents."[18][19]

Following its passage, Republicans in the House of Representatives introduced the Stop the Sexualization of Children Act, a bill largely based on the act in Florida.

During the nomination of Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson in 2022, Senator Marsha Blackburn accused Jackson of having a "hidden agenda" to restrict parental rights and expand government reach into schools.[20]

As of 2023, 20 states have had their legislatures introduce derivative bills of the Parental Rights in Education Act, including Arizona,[21] Georgia,[22] Iowa,[23][24] Kentucky, Louisiana, Michigan,[25] Missouri,[26] Ohio,[27] Oklahoma,[28] Tennessee, and South Carolina.[29][30] In April 2022, Alabama became the second state to pass a similar bill, with Governor Kay Ivey signing House Bill 322, legislation which additionally requires all students to use either male or female bathrooms in Alabama public schools based on their biological sex. Some states have had similar provisions to Florida's law since the 1980s, though they were never called Don't Say Gay bills by critics until the 2020s.[31][32]

Many potential candidates for the 2024 Republican Party presidential primaries made parental rights a major theme of their platform. Focusing on school literature with racial or sexual content, parental control over curriculum, and LGBT education, possible candidates like Glenn Youngkin, Ron DeSantis, and Donald Trump have endorsed the goals of the parental rights movement. Coverage in CNN has described this use of "parents' rights" as "an umbrella term for a host of cultural issues".[33]

Canada

edit

In 2009, Alberta passed an act that—while enshrining the rights of sexual minorities—also included a provision that would give parents the option of pulling their children out of lessons when topics related to sex, religion, or sexual orientation were taught.[3] It was referred to as a "parental rights clause" in the media.[34]

Prior to the start of the 2023 school year, the province of New Brunswick altered a policy affecting both formal and informal name changes at school, and the ability of students to choose their preferred pronouns. The revised Policy 713 (Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Policy) denied students under the age of sixteen the right to make changes to their personal preferences without first receiving parental consent.[35] The province's Minister of Education, Bill Hogan, stated that the policy review which led to the changes had been prompted by complaints from parents.[36] The policy review was controversial, and along with concerns about Premier Blaine Higgs's leadership style, led to calls during the summer for a review of his leadership of the Progressive Conservative Party of New Brunswick.[37] In response, the Christian conservative activist Faytene Grasseschi started a campaign called "Don't Delete Parents", encouraging people to sign a petition in support of Higgs, to pledge support for "pro-parent" political candidates, and to promote the idea that tax dollars should "follow the family" if parents chose to withdraw their children from the public school system in favour of homeschooling or private schools.[38][39]

In the same year, Saskatchewan also introduced a policy requiring parental consent for children who wished to change their names or pronouns in school and placing restrictions on sexual health education.[40] Following a judicial injunction against the policy, Premier Scott Moe announced that he would invoke the Constitution's Notwithstanding clause to override the decision and bring the policy into law.[41] On October 20, 2023, the government invoked the notwithstanding clause and passed the Parents' Bill of Rights.[42] A national Christian lobbying group called "Action4Canada" has taken credit for influencing the Saskatchewan Party government towards the policy.[43]

In September 2023, Ontario Premier Doug Ford accused school boards in the province of "indoctrinating" students on gender identity,[7] and stated that parents should be involved with decisions around pronoun use at schools.[4][44]

In the lead-up to the 2023 Manitoba general election in October 2023, the Progressive Conservative Party led by Heather Stefanson promised expanded parental rights in schools.[45] Stefanson's party was defeated by Wab Kinew's New Democratic Party.[46]

Federally, Conservative Party of Canada members adopted a resolution to prohibit "medicinal or surgical interventions" for gender-diverse and transgender kids at the party's 2023 policy convention.[47] Party leader—and leader of the Opposition—Pierre Poilievre has said that schools should leave LGBT issues to parents.[48]

In 2023, the "1 Million March 4 Children" was a series of parental rights protests carried out in various cities throughout Canada.[49][50] The protesters included adults and students, who claimed that children were being exposed to inappropriate topics regarding sexuality and gender identity and that students in some Canadian schools were being encouraged by teachers to change their pronouns and get "body-altering surgery" without parental knowledge.[49][51] The protests drew significant counter-protests.[49][51]

Europe

edit

France

edit

In 2022, following the addition of a gender-neutral pronoun to French dictionaries, French Minister of Education Jean-Michel Blanquer insisted that it was "not the future of the French language" and banned its use in schools.[52][53][54]

Ireland

edit

In Ireland, groups such as the Irish Education Alliance and religious bodies such as the Catholic Secondary School Parents Association have opposed the government's introduction of mandatory education about gender identity, pornography, and sexuality, which they perceive as overriding the ethos and rights of parents and schools.[55]

Impact on LGBT youth

edit
 
Pro-LGBT students in New Brunswick, Canada conducting a walkout protest against parental rights movement induced changes to the province's Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity policy.

Opponents of the parental rights movement argue that the policy would result in forcibly out children to parents or guardians who may not be accepting of their gender or sexual identities. In Canada, opponents such as Marci Ien, the Minister for Women and Gender Equality and Youth, has said that requiring parental consent to use different names or preferred pronouns places trans children in a "life or death situation."[10] In the United States, organised opposition like the Human Rights Campaign oppose the expansion of bills that limit LGBT freedom and expression in schools, suggesting they "stigmatize and marginalize" the LGBT community.[9]

Critics of the parental rights movement include parents,[56] teachers,[57] students,[56][58] human rights groups,[59] and corporations.[60] They argue that policies which forcibly out LGBT children can be damaging or life-threatening to those with unsupportive families.[8][10][61][62] Such policies have garnered significant concern due to the claimed potential for adverse consequences, including emotional distress, harm to mental well-being, and life-threatening situations for those affected, and can exacerbate issues such as depression, anxiety, and self-esteem problems.[63][64] It has been suggested that these issues may lead to long-term emotional scars and negatively impacting their overall quality of life.[65]

Additionally, critics highlight that the parental rights movement's insistence on parental control over a child's disclosure of their LGBT identity can perpetuate discrimination and prejudice. By prioritizing parental rights over a child's autonomy, these policies may inadvertently discourage open and honest communication within families, hindering the ability of LGBT youth to seek support or understanding from their loved ones.[66]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ a b Bouie, Jamelle (March 28, 2023). "Opinion | What the Republican Push for 'Parents' Rights' Is Really About". The New York Times. Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  2. ^ a b c Alfonseca, Kiara; Kekatos, Mary (September 14, 2023). "Debate over 'parental rights' is the latest fight in the education culture wars". ABC News. Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  3. ^ a b c Benchetrit, Jenna (September 23, 2023). "Where did the term 'parental rights' come from?". CBC News. Retrieved October 29, 2023.
  4. ^ a b c Mulligan, Cynthia (September 11, 2023). "Ford weighs in on boards telling parents about children's pronouns amid Greenbelt scandal". City News. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  5. ^ Benchetrit, Jenna (April 4, 2023). "How the parental rights movement resurged in response to trans inclusivity in classrooms". CBC. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  6. ^ Mosleh, Omar (July 30, 2023). "As two provinces limit pronoun changes in schools, what actually are parents' — and kids' — rights?". Toronto Star. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  7. ^ a b Cohen, Ben (September 10, 2023). "Doug Ford takes aim at Ontario school boards over 'indoctrinating' students on gender identity". Toronto Star. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  8. ^ a b Alam, Hina (June 12, 2023). "New Brunswick child advocate offers critique of province's school LGBTQ policy". Toronto Star. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  9. ^ a b Wamsley, Laurel (October 21, 2022). "What's in the so-called Don't Say Gay bill that could impact the whole country". NPR. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  10. ^ a b c Taylor, Stephanie (August 31, 2023). "Saskatchewan, New Brunswick naming changes means 'life or death' for trans kids: Ien". Toronto Star. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  11. ^ Benchetrit, Jenna (April 8, 2023). "How the parental rights movement resurged in response to trans inclusivity in classrooms". CBC. Retrieved September 14, 2023.
  12. ^ Watkins, Andra (June 8, 2023). "Call the push for so-called Parent's Rights what it is: far-right authoritarian theocracy". Salon. Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  13. ^ Lett, Dan (September 15, 2023). "Opinion: Tories' platform tilts precariously on 'parental rights'". Winnipeg Free Press. Retrieved September 16, 2023.
  14. ^ King, Jon (September 11, 2023). "Meet the parents who say their rights are ignored by the 'parental rights' movement ⋆ Michigan Advance". Michigan Advance. Retrieved September 19, 2023.
  15. ^ Caruso, Catherine (March 9, 2022). "The Parental Rights Movement Is History Repeating Itself". Dame Magazine. Retrieved September 19, 2023.
  16. ^ Clark, LaToya Baldwin (May 2023). "The Critical Racialization of Parents' Rights". Yale Law Journal. 132 (7). Retrieved September 21, 2023.
  17. ^ Schultz, Brooke (November 14, 2022). "EXPLAINER: The history behind 'parents' rights' in schools". AP News. Retrieved September 21, 2023.
  18. ^ Asencio-Rhine, Martha (March 16, 2022). "Here's what Florida's 'Don't Say Gay' bill would do, and what it wouldn't do". NBC News.
  19. ^ "House Bill 1557 (2022) - The Florida Senate". www.flsenate.gov.
  20. ^ Rahman, Khaleda (March 22, 2022). "Marsha Blackburn Accused of Racism Over Ketanji Brown Jackson Questions". Newsweek. Retrieved September 14, 2023.
  21. ^ Migdon, Brooke (September 30, 2022). "Arizona students protest new laws targeting LGBTQ+ community". The Hill. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  22. ^ Bellamy-Walker, Tat (March 10, 2022). "Georgia legislators introduce a Florida-style 'Don't Say Gay' bill". NBC News. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  23. ^ Ta, Linh (January 12, 2023). "'Don't Say Gay' bill introduced by Iowa Republican leaders". Axios. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  24. ^ "Iowa Legislature - Senate File 2024". legis.iowa.gov. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  25. ^ Hope, Jamie A. (December 5, 2022). "Michigan bill mirrors Florida's Parental Rights in Education law". Michigan Capitol Confidential. Archived from the original on March 21, 2023. Retrieved March 21, 2023.
  26. ^ "'Don't say gay' bill a hot issue in Mo". KFVS-TV. April 25, 2012. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  27. ^ "House Bill 616 | 134th General Assembly | Ohio Legislature". legislature.ohio.gov. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  28. ^ Rosa-Figueroa, Alex (April 27, 2022). "'Don't Say Gay' law filed in Oklahoma". KSWO-TV. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  29. ^ "Session 124 - (2021-2022) - South Carolina Legislature". Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  30. ^ Jones, Dustin; Franklin, Jonathan (April 11, 2022). "Not just Florida. Missouri and a wave of other states propose so-called 'Don't Say Gay' bills". KCUR 89.3 - NPR in Kansas City. Archived from the original on January 14, 2023. Retrieved January 14, 2023.
  31. ^ Sosin, Kate (April 21, 2022). "In some states, versions of 'Don't Say Gay' bills have been around for awhile". PBS NewsHour. Archived from the original on February 19, 2023. Retrieved November 14, 2022.
  32. ^ "Alabama HB322 | 2022 | Regular Session". LegiScan. Archived from the original on November 14, 2022. Retrieved November 14, 2022.
  33. ^ Orr, Gabby; Contorno, Steve (February 4, 2023). "Republicans elevate 'parental rights' as top issue while looking to outflank each other heading into 2024 | CNN Politics". CNN. Retrieved September 21, 2023.
  34. ^ "Alberta bill enshrining parental rights moves to final reading". CBC News. May 27, 2009. Retrieved October 29, 2023.
  35. ^ Ibrahim, Hadeel (August 23, 2023). "N.B. digs in on rules for teachers and name, pronoun use of LGBTQ students". CBC. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  36. ^ Cox, Aidan (May 10, 2023). "Complaints from parents, teachers prompted review of gender policy: N.B. education minister". CBC. Archived from the original on May 12, 2023. Retrieved May 12, 2023.
  37. ^ Poitras, Jacques (July 14, 2023). "Christian conservative group recruiting thousands to back Higgs". CBC News New Brunswick.
  38. ^ Poitras, Jacques (July 18, 2023). "No plans to let parents shift tax dollars out of public schools, N.B. premier says". CBC News New Brunswick.
  39. ^ "3 Goals". Don't Delete Parents. Retrieved December 12, 2023.
  40. ^ Simes, Jeremy (August 22, 2023). "Saskatchewan government says schools must seek parental consent for name, pronoun change". National Post. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  41. ^ Alphonso, Caroline (September 28, 2023). "Saskatchewan to invoke notwithstanding clause over school pronoun policy". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved September 29, 2023.
  42. ^ Hunter, Adam (October 20, 2023). "Sask. government passes Parents' Bill of Rights". CBC News. Archived from the original on October 20, 2023. Retrieved January 4, 2024.
  43. ^ Simes, Jeremy (September 8, 2023). "'We are not backing down': Premier Moe says legislation on parental rights coming this fall". CBC News. Archived from the original on September 9, 2023. Retrieved January 4, 2024.
  44. ^ Aguilar, Bryann (September 8, 2023). "Ford says it's important parents are informed about children's decisions amid debate over pronouns in schools". CP24. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  45. ^ MacLean, Cameron (August 17, 2023). "Manitoba PCs promise expanded parental rights in schools if re-elected". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved October 13, 2023.
  46. ^ "This just in: 2023 Manitoba election". Winnipeg Free Press. October 3, 2023. Retrieved October 4, 2023.
  47. ^ Taylor, Stephanie (September 9, 2023). "Conservative grassroots vote against surgical, pharmaceutical care for transgender kids". CTV News. The Canadian Press. Archived from the original on September 10, 2023. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  48. ^ Cullen, Catherine (August 28, 2023). "Poilievre says schools should leave LGBTQ issues to parents". CBC. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  49. ^ a b c Dickson, Courtney; Kurjata, Andrew (September 20, 2023). "Hundreds show up at rallies for and against teaching gender diversity in B.C. schools". CBC News. Retrieved September 20, 2023.
  50. ^ Mason, Corinne L.; Hamilton, Leah (September 20, 2023). "How the 'parental rights' movement gave rise to the 1 Million March 4 Children". The Conversation. Retrieved September 30, 2023.
  51. ^ a b "Cross-country rallies against 'gender ideology' in schools met with counter-protests". CTVNews. September 20, 2023. Retrieved September 20, 2023.
  52. ^ Samuel, Henry; Luyken, Jörg; Badcock, James; Squires, Nick (June 7, 2023). "In Europe the gender row isn't just over pronouns – it's the entire language". Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  53. ^ Rule, Misty Shock (March 17, 2022). "New volume on gender-neutral language sheds light on political controversy in France". UW News. Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  54. ^ Cheng, Amy (November 18, 2021). "A French dictionary added a gender-neutral pronoun. Opponents say it's too 'woke.'". Washington Post. Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  55. ^ O'Brien, Carl (February 6, 2023). "Sharp division over teaching of gender identity and use of pronouns in updated sex education syllabus". The Irish Times. Retrieved September 15, 2023.
  56. ^ a b "Florida Parents and Students Challenge 'Don't Say Gay' Law as Harmful and Unconstitutional". Family Equality Council. March 31, 2022. Archived from the original on February 14, 2023. Retrieved February 14, 2023.
  57. ^ Anton, Jessie (September 5, 2023). "Sask. teachers prepare to navigate new name, pronoun policy as school year begins". CBC. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  58. ^ Vera, Amir; Alvarado, Caroll (March 7, 2022). "Florida students participate in massive walkout to protest the 'Don't Say Gay' bill". CNN. Archived from the original on November 3, 2022. Retrieved November 8, 2022.
  59. ^ Luneau, Delphine (March 28, 2022). "BREAKING: Human Rights Campaign, Equality Florida Vow to Fight for Full Repeal of Vile, Dangerous New Law Signed by Florida Governor DeSantis". Human Rights Campaign. Archived from the original on December 17, 2022. Retrieved December 17, 2022.
  60. ^ "Business Statement on Anti-LGBTQ State Legislation". Human Rights Campaign. Archived from the original on February 15, 2023. Retrieved February 14, 2023.
  61. ^ "Transgender youth: 'Forced outing' bills make schools unsafe". AP NEWS. March 22, 2023. Retrieved May 12, 2023.
  62. ^ Austen, Andrea; Wellington, Adrian Alex (January 1995). "Outing: The Supposed Justifications". Canadian Journal of Law & Jurisprudence. 8 (1): 83–105. doi:10.1017/S084182090000309X. ISSN 0841-8209. S2CID 157003926.
  63. ^ Diaz, Jaclyn (March 28, 2022). "Florida's governor signs controversial law opponents dubbed 'Don't Say Gay'". NPR. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  64. ^ "'Don't Say Gay' bill becomes law in Florida, banning sexual orientation instruction from K-3". CBC. Associated Press. March 28, 2022. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
  65. ^ Kline, NS; Griner, SB; Neelamegam, M; Webb, NJ; Morales, JJ; Rhodes, SD (2022). "Responding to 'Don't Say Gay' Laws in the US: Research Priorities and Considerations for Health Equity". Sexuality Research & Social Policy. 19 (4): 1397–1402. doi:10.1007/s13178-022-00773-0. PMC 9666954. PMID 36406660.
  66. ^ Ibrahim, Hadeel (June 22, 2023). "5 questions answered about the LGBTQ school policy debate". CBC. Retrieved September 13, 2023.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Parental_rights_movement&oldid=1261478894"