Piano Sonata in G major, D 894 (Schubert)
The Piano Sonata in G major D. 894, Op. 78 by Franz Schubert is a sonata for solo piano, completed in October 1826.[1] The work is sometimes called the "Fantasie", a title which the publisher Tobias Haslinger, rather than Schubert, gave to the first movement of the work.[2] It was the last of Schubert's sonatas published during his lifetime, and was later described by Robert Schumann as the "most perfect in form and conception" of any of Schubert's sonatas.[3] A typical performance runs approximately 35 minutes.
The autograph manuscript of the sonata is preserved in the British Library.
Movements
edit
The sonata consists of four movements:
- Molto moderato e cantabile (G major, largely conforming to sonata form)
- Andante (D major, with two trios, the first in B minor, the relative minor, and the second in the parallel minor, D minor)
- Menuetto: Allegro moderato - Trio (B minor, trio in B major)
- Allegretto (G major)
Mood and character
editThe English pianist Imogen Cooper has described the G major sonata as "one of the rare completely serene sonatas that he wrote," adding, "Of course, as ever with him, there are contrasting passages which become stormy and a little bit dark, but the overall mood is one of peace and luminosity, in a way that the G Major string quartet, written a few months before, was most definitely not". She noted further that "the last movement has tremendous wit in it — and one or two moments of great poignancy, as if a cloud suddenly covered the sun, and then the sun comes out again".[4]
Pianist Mark Taratushkin, in his analysis of Schubert's Piano Sonata in G Major, D. 894,[5] points out that the original concept for the second movement was quite different from the version known today. Evidence of this can be seen in the score that Schubert sent to his publisher. The original manuscript, which has survived and is currently digitized in the archive of the London Library, reveals that after completing the minuet, Schubert decided to rewrite the second movement. He tore out the original version from the manuscript and replaced it with the version we know today. The first and last pages of the original movement were reused as the end of the first movement and the beginning of the third movement, respectively.
This peculiar aspect of the manuscript offers valuable insight into how the second movement might have originally sounded. The preserved fragment reveals a theme that is rhythmically characteristic of Schubert’s music, though it was ultimately replaced by a more dynamic orchestral episode in the final version. This change allowed for a greater contrast between the first two themes, which was crucial for the movement's structure and overall impact.
The third movement's opening theme is remarkably similar to the second theme of the first movement of Schubert's second Piano Trio both in rhythm and note progression.
Peter Pesic commented on Donald Francis Tovey's observation that Schubert used a "circle of sixths" series of key signatures in the fourth movement of this sonata, in the sequence G → E♭ → B = C♭ → G = A
.[6]
Pianists Sviatoslav Richter and Paul Lewis stated that this was their favourite Schubert sonata.[7][8] The former is notable for his extremely slow interpretation of the first movement,[9] and solemn account of the work, making the whole sonata usually last over 45 minutes in total. For Christian Zacharias this Schubert’s sonata belongs to beloved composition.
References
edit- ^ Newbould, Brian (1997). Schubert, the music and the man. Internet Archive. Berkeley : University of California Press. p. 328. ISBN 978-0-520-21065-3.
- ^ McCreless, Patrick (Spring 1997). "A Candidate for the Canon? A New Look at Schubert's Fantasie in C Major for Violin and Piano". 19th-Century Music. 20 (3): 205–230. doi:10.1525/ncm.1997.20.3.02a00020. JSTOR 746862.
- ^ Grant Hirosima, for LAPhil.com.
- ^ Imogen Cooper interview on BBC Radio 3, included in broadcast of Schubert piano recital on May 1, 2009
- ^ "Analysis of Schubert's Piano Sonata in G Major, Op. 78, D. 894 by Mark Taratushkin".
- ^ Pesic, Peter (Autumn 1999). "Schubert's Dream". 19th-Century Music. 23 (2): 136–144. doi:10.1525/ncm.1999.23.2.02a00020. JSTOR 746920.
- ^ "- YouTube". YouTube.
- ^ Tom Service (March 19, 2012). "Schubert: Ferocious, tender, sublime". The Guardian. Retrieved June 7, 2022.
- ^ Stephen Johnson reports on the 21-CD 'authorised' edition : "The first movement of Schubert's G major Sonata, D 894, is breathtakingly slow - the opening hardly seems to move at all. Richter's argument is that Schubert's marking, Molto moderato, refers to the quaver beat, not the dotted crotchet. In pure musicological terms, I don't imagine many Schubertians will be convinced, yet somehow Richter's concentrated, intensely absorbed playing persuaded me to suspend disbelief".
External links
edit- Piano Sonata in G major, D. 894: Schubert's autograph manuscript in the British Library
- Piano Sonata D.894: Scores at the International Music Score Library Project
