Talk:Dalmatia

Latest comment: 14 days ago by Ponor in topic Unsourced, original research

Ethnicity of inhabitants of Dalmatian

edit

There is no evidence from analysis of ethnic ancestry of present population of Dalmatia inffered from the Y-chromosome haplogroup distribution data to back the claim that ethnic origin of Fetivi, Boduli and Vlaji as distinct groups of people reflects different ethnic backgrounds, as the article claims. It should be removed from the article as the citations provided do no prove such a claim. Cultural differences between those groups, which are indeed prominent and discussed in the cited articles, are also largely intermixed and much more complex than what this article claims, as they involve high degree of regional specificity. 78.1.111.12 (talk) 22:04, 5 November 2024 (UTC)Reply

The article doesn't claim they are distinctive ethnic identities or having different ethnic origin. However, the paragraph does seem to be poorly sourced and mention of that information - which is almost trivial - doesn't seem as a part of necessary scope of the article.--Miki Filigranski (talk) 22:47, 5 November 2024 (UTC)Reply

Unsourced, original research

edit

Today's reverted edit caught my eye... Large parts of the article are without references, or are original research, or misrepresentation of the sources (cherry-picked data, comments nowhere to be found in the sources), etc. I've marked only a few in Special:Diff/1256323131, and am asking for proper sourcing with no original research. Because a lack of content is better than misleading or false content, unsourced content may be challenged and removed. Thank you. Ponor (talk) 10:22, 9 November 2024 (UTC)Reply