Stephen Thomas Erlewine of AllMusic derides the album, calling it "overproduced, overwrought and under-written" and, while praising their rendition of Tom T. Hall's "Me and Jesus", laments that "the bombastic production gets a little nerve-wracking about halfway through the album, and by the end of the record the music hasn't provided much inspiration. In all, a wasted opportunity."
- "We Love to Sing About Jesus" (Tammy Wynette, Earl Montgomery) – 1:54
- "Old Fashioned Singing" (Wynette, Earl Montgomery) – 2:50
- "He Is My Everything" (Dallas Frazier) – 2:55
- "Me and Jesus" (Tom T. Hall) – 3:14
- "Noah and the Ark" (Carmol Taylor, Jenny Strickland) – 2:26
- "Let's All Go Down to the River" (Sue Richards, Earl Montgomery) – 2:35
- "Let's All Sing Ourselves to Glory" (Earl Montgomery) – 2:11
- "Talkin' About Jesus" (Earl Montgomery) – 2:25
- "When Jesus Takes His Children Home" (Duke Goff, Mark Sherrill) – 1:46
- "Everything's Gonna Be Alright" (Bobby Womack, Carmol Taylor) – 1:52
- "Show Him That You Love Him" (Carmol Taylor, A. Wilson) – 1:54