Talk:The Conquest of the Italian Peninsula by the Carpatho - Danubians

Latest comment: 14 years ago by Herostratus in topic "See also"
edit

There was an External link section in the article with this one link:

But the article is mostly just generalities and, where specifics are given, there seems to be nothing about Italy, Carpath-Danubians, early Latin, or anything like that. So I removed it. Herostratus (talk) 20:39, 22 September 2010 (UTC)Reply

Rachet quote

edit

There was a referenced quote from Guy Rachet. However, the translation is poor and I could not really get a precise enough sense of what he was trying to say, and the French original is offline, so I removed it. It was:

Guy Rachet writes: "The Neolithic is a contribution from outside Italy, [...] is due Danubian peasants"<ref>Guy Rachet, Dictionnaire de l'archéologie, Paris, 1983</ref>.

maps

edit

I removed the maps from the article on the grounds that 1) They are much to general to illustrate the concept, and 2) this seems to be some kind of fringe theory, and the maps kind of WP:MASK this by implying that all this has been laid out geographically. The maps were:

 
3500 BC
 
2500 BC
 
1500 BC

Herostratus (talk) 21:05, 22 September 2010 (UTC)Reply

"See also"

edit

I'm not super happy with the "See also" section, as the links provided don't appear to really have much to do with the theory, at least not directly. Persons visiting these links would find interesting information about the early Romanians but not (in my quick scan) anything about early Latin coming from the Balkans. But I'm leaving them anyway. Herostratus (talk) 21:10, 22 September 2010 (UTC)Reply